| Date | Transaction |
| 02-28-1995 | Jim Rutherford has retired from the Phoenix Prowlers. |
| 09-04-1994 | The Phoenix Prowlers have moved Red Fields to the active roster. The Phoenix Prowlers have moved Jim Rutherford to the inactive roster. |
| 09-02-1990 | The Phoenix Prowlers have moved Johnny Agee, Ed Clark, Jim Rutherford, Jon Fleming, and Tim Armstrong to the active roster. The Phoenix Prowlers have moved Dave Skrepenak, Brad White, A.L. Magee, and Patsy Sarducci to the inactive roster. |
| 08-12-1990 | The Phoenix Prowlers have moved Brad White, Jim Hayes, Bill Critchfield, Warren Tomberlin, Alva Copeland, A.L. Magee, and Jim Mraz to the active roster. The Phoenix Prowlers have moved Johnny Agee, Ed Clark, Grant Scales, Jim Rutherford, Chester Morrissey, Brice Turner, Paul Coryatt, and Tim Armstrong to the inactive roster. |
| 10-07-1985 | Trade #73643 has been completed between the Cleveland Ironmen and the Phoenix Prowlers. The Phoenix Prowlers receive Jim Rutherford (C) from the Cleveland Ironmen in exchange for Bill Cronin (C). |
| 09-02-1985 | The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Jim Rutherford and Bruno Sammartino to the active roster. The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Bob Collie and Buzzy Offenhauser to the inactive roster. |
| 04-28-1985 | The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Jack Williams, Bob Collie, Mitch Sunde, Ezra Elzey, and Buzzy Offenhauser to the active roster. The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Albie Ra, Jim Rutherford, Big Ed Roebuck, Bruno Sammartino, and Charlie Pasteryak to the inactive roster. |
| 12-20-1982 | The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Altie Taylor, Andy Studebaker, and Jim Rutherford to the active roster. The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Rufus Bigbee, Jack Frost, and Nick Pietrosante to the inactive roster. |
| 12-06-1982 | The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Rufus Bigbee, Sixten Blixt, Jack Frost, and Bobby Ruhl to the active roster. The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Matt Byrd, Troy Tempest, Jim Rutherford, and Floyd Wilcox to the inactive roster. |
| 11-15-1982 | The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Raymond Barry, Matt Byrd, Troy Tempest, and Jim Rutherford to the active roster. The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Sixten Blixt, Jack Frost, Brad Dowler, and Bobby Ruhl to the inactive roster. |
| 10-31-1982 | The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Jack Frost to the active roster. The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Jim Rutherford to the inactive roster. |
| 10-25-1982 | The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Jim Rutherford to the active roster. The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Jack Frost to the inactive roster. |
| 10-11-1982 | The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Rufus Bigbee, Brad Dowler, and Jack Frost to the active roster. The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Andy Katzenmoyer, Jim Rutherford, and Raymond Barry to the inactive roster. |
| 09-27-1982 | The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Raymond Barry, Andy Studebaker, Tommy Gunn, Troy Tempest, Jim Rutherford, and Andy Katzenmoyer to the active roster. The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Rufus Bigbee, Olen Underwood, Jack Frost, Brad Dowler, Bobby Ruhl, and Mike Cropper to the inactive roster. |
| 09-20-1982 | The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Rufus Bigbee, Paul Bingham, Jack Frost, Brad Dowler, Bobby Ruhl, Ed Postupak, and Mike Cropper to the active roster. The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Raymond Barry, Andy Studebaker, Tommy Gunn, Troy Tempest, Jim Rutherford, Blair Johns, and Andy Katzenmoyer to the inactive roster. |
| 01-04-1982 | The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Matt Byrd, Frosty Rucker, Don Milk, Troy Tempest, Jim Rutherford, Joe Kline, and Raymond Barry to the active roster. The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Blair Johns, Rob Moroso, Andy Katzenmoyer, Jack Frost, Bobby Ruhl, Bob Alex, and Willie Roberts to the inactive roster. |
| 12-21-1981 | The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Blair Johns, Rufus Bigbee, Rob Moroso, Jack Frost, Bobby Ruhl, and Bob Alex to the active roster. The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Matt Byrd, Don Milk, Troy Tempest, Andy Katzenmoyer, Jim Rutherford, and Joe Kline to the inactive roster. |
| 11-16-1981 | The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Matt Byrd, Don Milk, Troy Tempest, and Jim Rutherford to the active roster. The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Rob Moroso, Jack Frost, Bobby Ruhl, and Bob Alex to the inactive roster. |
| 11-16-1981 | The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Rob Moroso, Jack Frost, Bobby Ruhl, and Bob Alex to the active roster. The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Matt Byrd, Don Milk, Troy Tempest, and Jim Rutherford to the inactive roster. |
| 09-14-1980 | The Cleveland Ironmen have changed Dan Hernandez's name to Jim Rutherford. |
| 08-04-1980 | The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Billy Faison, Izzy Taylor, Mitch Sunde, John Smith, Willie Rockwell, Dan Hernandez, David Kofler, Wayne Broughton, Moe Barber, Don Sweet, Freddie Hueller, Mel Winther, Greg Moore, Shelly Lansford, Elijah Coltrane, and Lane Taylor to the active roster. The Cleveland Ironmen have moved Mack Jacox, Raymond Barry, Patsy Donovan, Mark Brown, Rex Kern, Tony Ventura, John Brockington, Brad Dowler, Buzzy Offenhauser, Bruiser Broadnax, Willie Roberts, Joe Jones, Ed Postupak, Ed Rusnock, Bob Collie, and Robbie See to the inactive roster. |
Center