| Date | Transaction |
| 02-28-1967 | Craig McGarity has retired from football. |
| 11-28-1966 | The Boston Liberty have waived Craig McGarity. |
| 11-28-1966 | The Boston Liberty have acquired Craig McGarity from the waiver wire. |
| 08-29-1966 | The Nashville Fusion have waived Craig McGarity. |
| 08-22-1966 | The Nashville Fusion have moved Craig McGarity to the inactive roster. |
| 11-14-1965 | Craig McGarity of the Houston Phantoms is injured with a hip contusion and is expected to be out for approximately 5 days. |
| 09-03-1962 | The Tampa Bay Horror have moved Craig McGarity to the active roster. The Tampa Bay Horror have moved Doug Beecher to the inactive roster. |
| 09-03-1962 | Trade #16796 has been completed between the Tampa Bay Horror and the Edmonton Mall Rats. The Edmonton Mall Rats receive Draft Pick - 1964 Round 3 (TB) from the Tampa Bay Horror in exchange for Craig McGarity (G). |
| 08-26-1962 | The Edmonton Mall Rats have moved Montreal Instateller, Baskin Robbins, and Express Barber to the active roster. The Edmonton Mall Rats have moved Craig McGarity, Travel Currency, and Charlie Donnell to the inactive roster. |
| 08-26-1962 | The Edmonton Mall Rats have moved Craig McGarity, Charlie Donnell, and Angelas Hair to the active roster. The Edmonton Mall Rats have moved Biagio Luggage to the inactive roster. |
| 08-19-1962 | The Edmonton Mall Rats have placed Craig McGarity on the trade block. |
| 08-06-1962 | The Edmonton Mall Rats have moved Walt Schmidt, Leroy Davis, Tres Chic, Wrapsand Smoothies, Len Bettis, Anthony Wallace, Bellissima Fashions, Travel Currency, Tom Carney, Beach Hut, Ernie Delaney, and Sam Whittington to the active roster. The Edmonton Mall Rats have moved Addition Elle, Dick Ford, World Waterpark, Craig McGarity, Learning Academy, Eye Care, Aces Grill, Montreal Instateller, Vine Vera, Wliiams Sonoma, Express Barber, Derrick Smith, Brian Lee, Jiggs AndW, American Apparel, Angelas Hair, and Clubber Lounge to the inactive roster. |
| 09-03-1961 | The Edmonton Mall Rats have moved Craig McGarity and Henry Wingate to the active roster. The Edmonton Mall Rats have moved Sam Whittington and Derrick Smith to the inactive roster. |
| 09-03-1961 | Trade #15676 has been completed between the Green Bay Greys and the Edmonton Mall Rats. The Edmonton Mall Rats receive Henry Wingate (WR), Tony Lewis (WR), Craig McGarity (G) from the Green Bay Greys in exchange for Draft Pick - 1963 Round 1 (EDM). |
| 08-28-1961 | The Green Bay Greys have removed Craig McGarity from the trade block. |
| 08-27-1961 | The Green Bay Greys have placed Craig McGarity on the trade block. |
| 04-30-1961 | The Green Bay Greys have moved Fred Harrison, Joe O'Neal, Blake Miller, Mac Barnhart, and Ralph Francis to the active roster. The Green Bay Greys have moved Adam Lusk, Craig McGarity, Richie Rebowe, Phil Zellner, Robert McGee, and Gale Cappelletti to the inactive roster. |
| 01-02-1961 | The Green Bay Greys have moved Craig McGarity to the active roster. The Green Bay Greys have moved Blake Miller to the inactive roster. |
| 12-26-1960 | The Green Bay Greys have moved Dick Holdman, Blake Miller, and Adrian Jones to the active roster. The Green Bay Greys have moved Craig McGarity, Joe O'Neal, and Jerry Lucas to the inactive roster. |
| 12-12-1960 | The Green Bay Greys have moved Craig McGarity to the active roster. The Green Bay Greys have moved Blake Miller to the inactive roster. |
| 12-05-1960 | The Green Bay Greys have moved Blake Miller to the active roster. The Green Bay Greys have moved Craig McGarity to the inactive roster. |
| 11-28-1960 | The Green Bay Greys have moved Craig McGarity to the active roster. The Green Bay Greys have moved Blake Miller to the inactive roster. |
| 11-21-1960 | The Green Bay Greys have moved Blake Miller to the active roster. The Green Bay Greys have moved Craig McGarity to the inactive roster. |
| 10-23-1960 | The Green Bay Greys have moved Craig McGarity to the active roster. The Green Bay Greys have moved Blake Miller to the inactive roster. |
| 10-10-1960 | The Green Bay Greys have moved Blake Miller to the active roster. The Green Bay Greys have moved Craig McGarity to the inactive roster. |
| 09-19-1960 | The Green Bay Greys have moved Craig McGarity to the active roster. The Green Bay Greys have moved Blake Miller to the inactive roster. |
| 09-19-1960 | The Green Bay Greys have moved Frank Rucker to the active roster. The Green Bay Greys have moved Craig McGarity to the inactive roster. |
| 09-19-1960 | The Green Bay Greys have acquired Craig McGarity from the waiver wire. |
| 09-11-1960 | The Baton Rouge Bayou Rangers have waived Craig McGarity. |
| 08-21-1960 | The Baton Rouge Bayou Rangers have moved Jimmy Burns, Chuck Robinson, Ozzie Brown, Mohammed Gray, Derwin Bassi, Wendell Gibson, Mike Ena, Clarence Bonner, Bruce Eidson, Steve Buckley, Clarence Seymour, and Sam Kacherski to the active roster. The Baton Rouge Bayou Rangers have moved Craig McGarity, Ollie Brumfield, Ben Tongue, Trusse Davis, Jim Heldt, Elvis Broadnax, Terry Knapp, Dario Kellogg, John Scafide, Brandon Golsteyn, John Burns, and Johnny Wilks to the inactive roster. |
| 08-14-1960 | The Baton Rouge Bayou Rangers have placed Craig McGarity on the trade block. |
| 08-08-1960 | The Baton Rouge Bayou Rangers have moved Tom Cowhig, Craig McGarity, Jim Heldt, John Burns, Elvis Broadnax, Babe Anderson, Bob Short, Randy Campbell, Keith Greene, Henry Howton, and Brandon Golsteyn to the active roster. |
Guard